Archives for category: Charter Schools

Stephen Dyer is a former legislator and current watchdog over Ohio spending on education. Dyer is skilled at reading the state budget. He reports that the vast majority of new funds for charter schools was spent on administrators’ salaries. Does the public know this?

Dyer reports:

The state released yet one more data point highlighting the need to greatly slim down Ohio’s bloated Charter School Program — last school year’s spending numbers for Ohio’s public and charter schools. 

And while for the first time in a few years, Ohio’s Charter Schools spent less per pupil, on average, than Ohio’s traditional public schools, it wasn’t by a lot. The average brick and mortar Ohio Charter School spent $17,291 per pupil last school year. Ohio’s traditional public schools spent $17,644 — about 2 percent more. 

Per Pupil expenditures for the 2025-2026 school year by school type

Remember that this is how much districts and charters spend in total, including all state, local and federal money. Only a handful of Ohio Charter Schools collect local revenue. So their expenditures are almost exclusively state sourced, with about the same percentage of federal funding that districts get. So the fact that charters and districts are in the same ballpark on relative spending is a remarkable testament to how generous the state had been to charters, especially in relation to the kids in local public school districts.

What’s most striking about these data, though, is how much of the overall spending in Charter Schools is on administrative, non-instructional costs. While not unusual (I’ve been writing about charters’ addiction to administrative expenses for years), what is amazing is how much more per pupil Charter Schools spend on administrators.

Brick and mortar charters spend nearly double the amount districts do and online schools spend a staggering $6,654 per pupil on administrators — more than 3 times the amount districts do. 

By way of comparison, Ohio’s online charters spend more per pupil on administrators than 293 Ohio public school districts receive in total per pupil state aid, according to the latest funding report. There are 613 Ohio public school districts.

More outrage?

Since 2023-2024, 98 percent of all online charter school spending growth has gone to administrative costs.

That’s right. Online charters cut their spending on instruction and staff support so that they could spend 98 percent of their $1,462 per pupil increase on administrators. The remaining $99 went to pupil support.

While online schools reveal the starkest change, brick and mortar charters ain’t much different.

Their increase for administrators is actually more than double their overall spending increase. How is that? Because they drastically cut operations and staff support funding. So while their overall spending only went up $116 per pupil, their administrative cost jumped $263.

Can you imagine the outcry if school districts spent their money this way?

Can you understand why I’ve always called bullshit on Ohio school choice advocates’ insistence on “putting more money into the classroom?” 

Because charters were sold as being a more efficient way to deliver more resources directly into the classroom — avoiding the school district administrative “bloat”. 

Instead, they are remarkably worse at delivering resources into classrooms than traditional public schools.

One more thing to chew on: If charters spent the same share of their funding on administrators that school districts did, it would save state taxpayers about $215 million. 

That’s just about what the state’s school funding formula calculates it costs for all traditional school district guidance counselors and staff professional development.

In all districts.

Like … combined.

Yet that’s how much more Ohio Charter Schools spend on administrators than they would if they just spent the same percentage of their money on administrators that Ohio’s public school districts do.

And what’s been the result? One in 3 charters ending up on the state’s worst-performing schools list, among other things.

Yeah. Trim that fat.

Woo Pig Sooie!

I wrote about Emily Hanford’s “Sold a Story 2” last week. Her first season (“Sold a Story”) was devoted to the assertion that reading teachers have been deceived and have failed to learn that phonics is the one best way to teach reading. I am a proponent of phonics but firmly believe that states should not mandate how to teach. I do not believe in a “science of reading” or a science of any other subject. There are many ways to be a good teacher, not a single method.

In season 2, Hanford discovers “Direct Instruction” and again asserts that teachers have been deceived by the education establishment, which (she says) prefers unscripted, loosey-goosey, “discovery” methods.

Hanford shows her hand in Episode 6 of the second season. She chooses to highlight the use of Direct Instruction at Baker Mitchell’s four-school charter chain in North Carolina. More than a decade ago, I wrote about Baker Mitchell and his charter chain (Roger Bacon Academy) as a prime example of profiteering and conflict of interest in charter world. It’s a strange choice for an exemplar.

Baker Mitchell operates his charters for profit and has collected millions of dollars from them. He is paid 16% of their revenues to manage them. He owns a separate for-profit company (Coastal Habitat Conservancy) to collect rent on land and buildings and sell supplies to the schools. Another Mitchell company sells school uniforms. He is an entrepreneur, not an educator. When the Tea Party won control of North Carolina in 2010, the hard-right Republicans in the state legislature passed a charter law in June 2011, and Baker Mitchell saw a business opportunity.

But! Hanford admired the fact that these charters used DI.

At this point, I am going to post part of the online discussion between Trevor Aleo and Nick Covington about “Sold a Story 2.”

They begin by writing: “‘Obedient and Loyal to Those in Authority”: The Charter Network Hanford Hoped You Wouldn’t Google.'”

I hope you are intrigued enough to read their commentary in full.

I am posting only the beginning.

Nick: I think I’ve been even-handed in my criticism of this season, so I ask forgiveness for the heel turn I’m about to make: Emily Hanford is lying to you and thinks you’re gullible. That’s my takeaway from Episode 6 after the most cursory Google search for Baker Mitchell, the charter school founder at the center of this week’s narrative. I can’t focus on anything else. The way Hanford frames Baker Mitchell and his charter school network—and what she omits to make it work in her favor—is the story, and all of my energy today has gone into bringing that to our readers.

Trevor: This was definitely the mask off episode of the season. I noted in our previous episode that Hanford at least attempted to hide the ideological underpinnings guiding the Sold A Story project, but this week we went from subtext to text in a fairly jarring manner. This episode was basically a really bad infomercial about charter schools from 2008. I joked last week that Hanford’s arguments were so recycled that it seems like she spent the last 20 years in a cryogenic chamber. After this week, I’m actually concerned it’s true. Maybe the American Enterprise Institute keeps her on ice when she isn’t podcasting on their behalf?

What Hanford Doesn’t Tell You About Baker Mitchell

Nick: Episode 6 opens innocuously enough, “Baker Mitchell is an engineer. He loves science. He was hoping his children would too,” followed by an interview clip of Mitchell talking about instilling a love of science for his own children, all of which led him to found a school. “That one school has become four,” Hanford says, “A group of charter schools in and around the city of Wilmington, North Carolina named for Roger Bacon, the 13th century scholar who helped develop the scientific method.” Much of the episode focuses on the experience of teachers, students, and parents at Roger Bacon Academy schools, emphasizing the call-and-response aspect of Direct Instruction.

About halfway through the episode, though, Hanford pauses, “A note: there has been controversy surrounding the Roger Bacon schools for reasons that have nothing to do with Direct Instruction — including a high-profile lawsuit about their dress code by the ACLU,” before picking the thread right back up, “We visited the Roger Bacon schools because Direct Instruction has lasted for 26 years…” Hold up. Controversy, dress code, and the ACLU? I wonder what’s going on there that Hanford felt it needed mention withoutelaboration? How has Direct Instruction survived for so long here where it hasn’t elsewhere? Here’s where a Google search undoes the narrative.

Baker Mitchell was an engineer, but he was also an entrepreneur. According to his CV, Mitchell built a successful computer software company and sold it off in 1989. He then spent the next decade writing courses and volunteer teaching before moving to North Carolina and opening The Roger Bacon Academy in 1999. Today there is no single school of Mitchell’s called Roger Bacon Academy. What Hanford describes as “a group of [four] charter schools in and around the city of Wilmington” are actually branded Classical Charter Schools of America and managed by Mitchell’s for-profit Roger Bacon Academy, Inc. Yet neither the classical charter brand nor the for-profit status show up anywhere in the episode.

In 2014, ProPublica investigated how Mitchell’s operation works. The schools themselves may be non-profits, but the non-profit school board hired the for-profit Roger Bacon Academy to manage them, with Baker Mitchell on both sides of the transaction. In other words, Mitchell hired himself, an arrangement ProPublica points out “is illegal in many other states.” He then sold or leased the schools nearly everything they needed—from desks, computers, and teacher training to the land and buildings themselves—with no competitive bidding. As early as 2001, the IRS denied the group’s application for tax-exemption and documented what they called “a clear conflict of interest” in Mitchell controlling the management company and the schools buying its services. That didn’t prevent him from taking $20 million in management fees and rent from just the first six years of his first two schools. None of Mitchell’s apparent self-dealing appears in the episode.

Trevor: But, Nick! Can you really put a price on children’s ability to retrieve knowledge from their long term memory? Caring about rampant self dealing, fraud, and corruption is so education establishment coded. Who taught you to care about that stuff? John Dewey? Jean-Jacques Rousseau? Good teaching isn’t political!

Nick: Funny you mention that, Trevor—Mitchell was also a political activist, putting his thumb on the scale of state policy in his favor. In 2011, the North Carolina state legislature raised the cap on charter schools and put Mitchell on the Charter School Advisory Council, whose job it was to review new charter applications. As the ProPublica piece documents, Mitchell’s schools suddenly benefitted from a number of “unusual” exemptions and exceptions. In 2013, Mitchell used his influence to push for new charter school regulations that loosened teacher certification rules and gave property managers like himself tax-breaks for leasing to charter schools. He eventually resigned from the state’s Charter School Advisory Board in 2014 after being dogged by questions about his impartiality and conflicts of interest. That Mitchell saw his education work as deeply political is mentioned nowhere in the episode, and that’s before we even get to the curriculum.

Classical Charter Schools

Nick: If you’re curious about the bit in the episode with middle-schoolers naming Roman emperors and taking Latin, that comes from the classical charter school angle, which “teaches a classical curriculum espousing the values of traditional western civilization.” That’s left out of the episode, along with the School Pledge taken directly from the 2026-2027 Parent and Student Handbook, which includes vows to guard against “the stains of falsehood from the fascination with experts…and the over-reliance on rational argument.” Bit of tension there for a podcast series about evidence-based practices, so I can understand not leading the episode with it, but the School Pledge then closes with this stanza:

I pledge to be obedient and loyal to those in authority

in my family,

in my school, and

in my community and country,

So long as I shall live.

Trevor: It feels like Hanford is making us speed run every bad right-wing education/policy fad from the last 15 years. In addition to all the issues with this particular charter school system, there are so many issues with the broader classical school movement that I feel like I have to start in the historical weeds and work my way back from there.

First of all, the idea that “the West” is an unbroken chain stretching from ancient Greece through Western Europe and ultimately culminating in a Disneyfied version of American exceptionalism is utter pish. The Western tradition is not some sacred heirloom of Christendom. The idea that Europe can “claim” Greece’s intellectual legacy as its property attempts to project modern borders onto ancient history as though they are timeless and static cultural boundaries. What these classical charter schools call “the Western tradition” was shaped by centuries of intellectual exchange across Europe, North Africa, and the Arabic-speaking world—not within a self-contained cultural space called “the West.” In fact, much of the Greek philosophy that helped transform medieval Europe, including the Trivium referenced in the CCSA materials above, reached Latin readers through Arabic-language scholarship and translation networks linking the Islamic world with Iberia and Siciliy. The Muslim and Jewish cultures and scholars (not just the Christian ones!) who kept this knowledge alive did not simply pass along an untouched Athenian inheritance; they translated, interpreted, challenged, extended, and generally enriched it.

This is not a purely pedantic point about historical accuracy. It proves that people like Mitchell know nothing of the history that they seek to venerate. They are either wholly cynical, treating the good, beautiful, and true as marketing buzzwords for CCSA promotional materials, or they are embarrassingly dim, eschewing the complex texture of history for smooth brained fairytales to reinforce their political priors. Either way, their celebration of “the West” is not born out of intellectual curiosity, a desire to live a more fully examined life, or even a belief students should engage with powerful ideas from the past. The entire project is just reactionary politics cosplaying the life of the mind. Nevermind the fact that it’s hard to take grandiose claims of value-based education seriously when, as you’ve already detailed, these schools basically become cash cows for entrepreneurial grifters seeking to better monetize their own liberal arts educations.

Please open the link and finish reading.

In the recent election, there were many inspiring stories of candidates who challenged the status quo and won. One of those stories is the triumph of Gina Hinojosa over Texas Governor Greg Abbott. Abbott had a huge war chest and the support of several billionaires, including Elon Musk.

The polls were not encouraging to Hinojosa. At best, the polls showed her within striking distance of Abbott. The pundits and pollsters took James Talarico seriously, but not Hinojosa. They didn’t think she had a chance.

But when all the votes were counted, Hinojosa beat Abbott by 7 points. Literally no one expected that.

Best of all, Hinojosa made public schools the centerpiece of her campaign. Wouldn’t it be great if other Democratic candidates noticed the power of that issue?

I can’t help wondering: would David Jolley have won the Governor’s race in Florida if he had put the Republican attack on public schools at the center of his campaign? Would Democrats in other states have captured the governor’s seat had they run as champions of the people’s schools and critics of the privatizers? Obviously, we can’t know, but those planning to run in 2028 should study Gina Hinojosa’s central message: Fighting for public schools is a winning issue.

Do you want to know what she said before she declared that she was running for Governor? In 2025, she was a keynote speaker at the conference of the Network for Public Education in Columbus, Ohio. If you want to know Gina, watch her speak to a room full of friends. This was before Governor Abbott dragged his odious voucher plan across the finish line.

Clearly, the public did not like what Abbott had done, which imperiled their schools and their communities.

Julian Vasquez-Heilig recently wrote about Gina Hinojosa’s improbable rise. It is an inspiring story.

Fourteen years ago, Gina Hinojosa was a mother fighting to save her son’s elementary school. Today, she is preparing to govern Texas. Sometimes the most extraordinary political journeys begin with something as ordinary, and as powerful, as a mother’s love.

In 2011, facing severe budget pressures compounded by inadequate state funding, the Austin Independent School District identified historic Pease Elementary as a potential closure. Imagine discovering that the place where your child was learning to read, making friends, and beginning to imagine his future might disappear because officials needed to reduce expenses. Imagine being told that the decision came down to budgets and efficiency, as though a spreadsheet could measure what a neighborhood school means to the families who love it.

Gina could have complained, signed a petition, and hoped somebody would listen. Instead, she organized with other parents, ran for the Austin school board in 2012, and won. Fourteen years later, that same mother is the governor-elect of Texas, having defeated Greg Abbott despite being dramatically outspent 8-1. The woman who once fought to protect her son’s school now has an opportunity to influence the education of approximately 5.5 million Texas public school students.

In 2016, Gina was elected to the Texas House of Representatives, where she was repeatedly re-elected.

Again, to quote Julian Vasquez-Heilig:

There is something extraordinary about that progression. Gina did not begin with a grand ambition to govern millions of people. She began with one school, one neighborhood, and parents afraid of losing something precious. Her responsibilities expanded from one district to the Legislature and now to the governor’s office. The very education policies that compelled her to challenge the status quo ultimately set her on a path to lead the state that created them, and gave her the opportunity to change them…

Gina Hinojosa’s extraordinary journey began with a fight to save her son’s elementary school and carried her all the way to the governor’s mansion. The very education policies that inspired her to challenge the system helped create the leader who now has an opportunity to transform it. Let Texas stop making headlines for fighting over education and start making history for improving it. And when future generations ask how it all began, let us tell them about a mother who stood up when her child’s school was threatened, who refused to be silenced, and who discovered that the love of a parent could become the beginning of something much greater.

Stephen Dyer has tracked charter schools over the years and knows their problems better than anyone else. They are very costly. Many have very low performance. They have enabled scandals and corruption due to lax oversight.

In this post, he presents his ideas about why charter legislation must change:

Yesterday, I discussed how Tuesday’s election results here and in Texas, as well as the political fallout therefrom will almost certainly result in the death knell for the ~ $1 billion EdChoice voucher program.

Today, it’s the Charter School program, which costs Ohio taxpayers 50 percent more than EdChoice annually. About $20 billion in total since 1998.

I’ve gone through this carnival of horrors many times, but let’s deal with the topline issues with Ohio’s Charter Schools.

  1. They receive 2 out of every 3 of failing grades on the most recent state report card
  2. More than 1 in 3 are on the state’s lowest-performing building list.
  3. More than 9 in 10 “Dropout Recovery” charters are on the list.
  4. About 1 in 5 charters have been on the list since 2018.
  5. More than 1 in 2 charter schools that have ever opened in Ohio are now closed.
  6. They received more than 1/2 of all F grades ever given to schools on Ohio’s Report Card, despite representing about 10% of all Ohio school buildings.
  7. They spend almost double the share of their funding on non-instructional administrators that Ohio’s traditional public schools spend.
  8. They receive more than double the state funding that a traditional Ohio public school student receives.
  9. They spend more, on average, per pupil than a traditional Ohio Public School District, even though charters can’t collect local revenue (except for a handful in Cleveland).
  10. They produced the single largest taxpayer ripoff scam in Ohio history, largely enabled by Sen. Jon Husted, and are constantly being busted for fraud and other corrupt practices.
  11. Charter School students are about 7 percent of the state’s school population, but receive 12 percent of the state’s funding for schools.
  12. That funding (along with EdChoice vouchers) is preventing the state from fully funding its own formula to provide resources to the state’s 1.5 million traditional public school students.
  13. More than 1 in 10 Ohio charter schools are on the state’s suspected test cheating list and 7 out of every 10 schools suspected of cheating on their state tests are charter schools.
  14. More than 1 in 4 of the state’s “high performing” charter schools are on the state’s suspected test cheating list.
  15. They have cost charter school graduates between $247 million and $321 million since 2018 and will cost them between $1.8 billion and $6.7 billion over their collective lifetimes.

A LOT to chew on there. But let’s deal with the three major issues overall issues with charters:

  1. They cost too much
  2. They perform too poorly
  3. They are scandal ridden

So how do we deal with each of these issues now? A few thoughts.

Costing too much

The original sin of Ohio Charter Schools is paying them like they cost the same to operate as traditional public schools. Under Ohio’s current Fair School Funding Plan, costs are calculated based on the overall cost of teachers, principals, administrative assistants, superintendents, treasurers, etc. for Ohio’s public school districts.

The issue with Ohio Charter Schools is they pay their people (except for administrators) way less than traditional schools. In fact, according to state data, they pay their teachers about 37 percent less. So just applying that lower teacher salary to the formula to pay Ohio Charter Schools cuts their funding by about $167 million.

Do that for principals, superintendents, treasurers, administrative assistants, etc. and you would realize additional cost savings.

In addition, you should limit their administrative costs to no more than 10 percent more than the average traditional public school. Currently, the average administrative expenditure in traditional public schools is about 13 percent of the overall spend. Limiting charters to just 10 percent more than that would free up another $210 million or so.

And online schools need a drastic reduction in state aid coupled with requirements to provide up-to-date computers and internet links. 

Brick and mortar charters and online schools need their own, separate funding formulas¹. 

Finally, tying per pupil funding for Charter Schools to no greater than what the state would have paid the school district of residence would also limit their funding to something that makes sense. If the state is paying $5,000 for a student to attend the local public school district, why should it pay $12,000 for that same student to attend a poorer performing charter school²?

Poor Performance

Which brings us to performance. 

Look, Ohio Charter School performance has always been pretty damn poor. The state only spent $8 million of the $71 million the state lied the Obama Administration into giving them a decade ago to grow high-quality Charters. Now we’ve got another $100 million in federal money to expand high-performing Charters here, but we have nowhere near that number of high-quality Charters.

So what can be done?

First, we need to immediately close Charters that have performance index scores that rank in the bottom 5 percent of Ohio public school districts³. If districts that score in the bottom 5 percent on Performance Index Score is bad enough to allow Charter Schools to open, certainly it’s fair that Charters who perform no better shouldn’t be operating and continue siphoning money away from kids in traditional public school districts.

Yes, those students would have to return to traditional public schools, but because the state pays so much more for those kids in Charters, there would also be savings when the kids return to the traditional public schools. Depending on how many years you’d want to include the 5 percent cut off⁴, you’d save $50 million to $450 million.

As for where would districts put these kids now? Just do to Charters what’s been done to Districts: Offer their buildings to the Districts that now need to take the kids at low to no cost. 

And no lottery money should be used to fund Charters. 

Like, ever.

Second, we need a much tighter automatic closure law that takes into account all the report card elements, not just cherry picked elements that put charters in the best light. So if a Charter underperforms the school district of residence from which the student is coming on more measures than it outperforms the district, the Charter can’t take the kid.

This is loosely based on a plan that former state Sen. Joe Schiavoni proposed more than a decade ago. Still works.

And if the Charter School does not outperform the lowest performing public school district in the state on more report card measures than it underperforms, it needs to close, regardless of whose kids the school takes. If you want to do this for two consecutive years or something, I’d listen.

Scandal Ridden

The primary issue with Ohio Charter Schools is their oversight is almost non existent. Yeah, they are audited every year, but as then-Auditor Dave Yost proved — that doesn’t mean they’re getting shut down. He gave the state’s highest auditing award to the Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow (ECOT) the same year they were actively ripping off taxpayers to the tune of $120 million plus. 

While more than 1/2 of all Ohio Charter Schools that have ever opened are now closed, only about 2 dozen of those closures were due to the state’s lax automatic closure law. 

In 2015, we tried putting the onus on Charter School Sponsors to take a more active approach to policing Charter School behavior — to great fanfare and hope from me. But that has largely failed because 1/3 of Ohio’s Charter Schools are on the state’s list of worst-performing schools. 

So here’s how to improve accountability and reduce the possibility of another ECOT scandal.

First, we ban for-profit operators from running Ohio Charter Schools. This is something former House Speaker (and current 20-year federal resident) Larry Householder proposed not long ago. Most states do not let private, for-profit companies to run their Charter Schools. Ohio should join them. Eliminating the profit motive should reduce costs as well, as I found back when Householder proposed the idea. For-profit schools spent about $1,200 more per pupil back then.

Second, we require that all charter school sponsors have to be publicly accountable entities. One of the elements that leads to us being deemed the Wild, Wild West of Charter Schools by Charter School advocates is that so many non-profits that have little to do with education run our Charter Schools, including an orphanage and a housing organization. This arrangement is almost unique in the country. 

Requiring Ohio Charter Schools to be run by school districts or the state would ensure more public accountability, as well as create better partnerships between the traditional and charter sectors — partnerships that have been nearly non-existent here as these schools were first and foremost a political, not an education reform project of big Republican campaign donors.

Finally, we need a transparent, KnowYourCharter.com-like state website where people can compare their schools and Charters easily and understandably. Sunshine is the best disinfectant, after all. 

Bottom Line

Doing these things will greatly reduce the taxpayer investment in Charter Schools, but will ensure a better Charter School program. Think quality, not quantity here. 

Would you rather have a huge Charter School program filled mostly with failed operations that cost state taxpayers more than school districts? Or fewer, higher performing schools that complement the traditional schools?

I have often differed with many public school advocates on Charter Schools. I have said they can work in limited circumstances. We have spent $20 billion and 30 years proving that they can’t work here in their current form as a broad-based education solution. 

As Charter School advocate Macke Raymond put it many years ago: Parental Choice has not improved education the way the School Choice advocates thought. 

That doesn’t mean Charter Schools can’t work in some form or fashion here. 

But I think we can all agree that after $20 billion and 30 years, this Charter School form is not working. 

They need to be reined in with the money saved from that re-directed to fully funding the state’s school funding formula and reducing the need and amount of property taxes collected.

It’s time for this program’s GLP-1 treatment.

Slimmer and better.

Our taxpayers and, most importantly, our kids deserve it.

To read the footnotes, open the link.

Veteran Educator Cassandra Mayes ran for the state legislature in Arkansas with no expectations about winning. As a Black woman in an overwhelmingly white district and as a Democrat in a solidly Republican district, she knew she was in an uphill race. She ran because she was compelled to give up her job due to budget cuts after the introduction of charters and then vouchers. She ran because she wants all schools–public, private, and home schools–to meet the same accountability standards. Governor Sarah Huckabee Sanders, who was Trump’s press secretary in his first term, introduced the voucher program called “Arkansas LEARNS.” The story appeared in the Arkansas Times.

Mayes has had a distinguished career of nearly 30 years as a teacher of students with disabilities and an administrator of state programs.

The story begins:

Cassandra Mayes, a longtime educator and political newcomer, made history Tuesday as the first Black woman and first Democrat elected to represent House District 71, which includes Maumelle and surrounding communities.

Mayes says she was inspired to run after Arkansas LEARNS led to cuts in her contract as a district-level administrator for the Little Rock School District, forcing her to leave a career she loved to care for her ailing mother. Now she’s headed to the Capitol with plans to challenge LEARNS, starting with greater accountability for private schools receiving public money through vouchers. 

Mayes faced an uphill battle in the Republican-held district, although her opponent, Stephen Bright, was dogged by allegations of domestic and child abuse that likely cost him the race. 

In an interview with the Arkansas Times, Mayes describes how she refused to let the scandals surrounding her opponent derail her campaign, and how she plans to challenge Arkansas LEARNS in a newly emboldened Democratic minority.

This interview has been edited for length and clarity. 

AT: Congratulations.

Mayes:  Thank you so much. I’m still trying to process everything.

AT: At what point last night did you realize you were going to win, and what was your reaction?

Mayes: I had been at the polls until about 7 o’clock, and I came home and got dressed, and I was going to kind of take my time before I went down to Mosaic Templars after the polls closed, and one of my team members had called me and said, “Cassandra, where are you?” I could tell in his voice that he wanted to say something, but he didn’t. I promised myself I would not check my phone or TV. And when I got to Mosaic Templars and was walking towards the war room, it was very quiet, and it concerned me. When I walked in, they said, “Cassandra, you did it.” I lost it. I cried. I knew we had a chance to flip the seat, but I just wasn’t sure because it had never been done before out here in Maumelle. 

I lost it. I cried. I knew we had a chance to flip the seat, but I just wasn’t sure because it had never been done before out here in Maumelle. Cassandra Mayes

AT: You’re a political newcomer. What do you want readers to know about you?

Mayes: I had personal experiences that brought me to this point. I did not grow up in a political family. Politics was close, but it wasn’t close enough for me to even have a desire. I saw it from afar, but what happened at the state level brought those experiences to me. One impacted my career that I worked very hard for and absolutely loved, and the other impacted the person that I loved the most, other than my child, and that was my mother. And those two issues collided at the same time. When my job was in jeopardy because of Arkansas LEARNS, and my mother entered a healthcare system that was not fair to her because of her pension as a retired educator, I knew that I could either talk about it and be angry or be a part of the solution. 

AT: Can you be more specific about how LEARNS put your own job in jeopardy?

Mayes: Yes, so when Arkansas LEARNS hit my employer [Little Rock School District], we were experiencing a decline in student enrollment prior to it hitting, and so when it hit, we had parents that were leaving the district, going to private charter-schools, and so the Education Freedom Accounts, the vouchers, basically were being utilized more. When you’re losing students, that impacts staffing and even facilities. So, my contract was substantially cut, going from a 12-month to a 10-and-a-half month employee, and the money loss basically equated to the money I was using to pay someone to stay home with my mother while I worked. 

I had to make a financial decision for my family to leave a career that I absolutely loved, but to take care of someone I loved more. And it’s something that I should not have had to do. I should have been able to continue to work, but also have someone that I trusted to stay with my mom. But I couldn’t afford it, and she didn’t qualify for support.

AT: What do you want to accomplish at the Capitol to strengthen public schools, and what do you think can realistically be done to push back on LEARNS?

Mayes: The first thing we need to do is have a courageous conversation of what’s going on statewide. In education, you’re taught in college that decisions you make regarding curriculum, even budgetary decisions at the school level, are data-driven, and under Arkansas LEARNS, we do not have data to support whether our schools and students are making progress because the assessment that is used is an assessment that was created for Arkansas and Arkansas only.

Under LEARNS, people are asking the question: People are utilizing the vouchers for school choice, but are the students performing at a rate that supports the need to continue the voucher program? Because parents using school choice make those decisions allegedly on academic progress and lack thereof, and under LEARNS, we have no system in place that shows us where a third grader is performing in a public school, a charter school, a private school or home school. At this point, we have no data to show how kids are performing across all of those educational options, and that is something that we must change. I support any entity that receives public funds should be held to the same standard as a public school. 

AT: Democrats flipped several seats in the state legislature last night. Obviously, they did very well across the country. But what do you think this means for the balance of power in Arkansas, and what realistically do you think will shift maybe because of the party picking up some seats last night.

Mayes: We did pick up some seats we were not expecting to pick up, so that means we were able to break the [Republican] supermajority in our legislature. What that tells us is that there is a level of synergy across the state, where we have been challenged as newly-elected officials. It also told the Republicans that people are not happy, and that change has to take place, and it’s telling all of us that we’re going to have to come together and have some conversations, and we’re going to have to make decisions outside of our personal opinions and focus on the people of this state. 

Last night told all of us a clear story that change was necessary. Change is here, and we’ve got to deal with it. And in order for us to change policies in place that will make people have a better quality of life, lower the cost of living, all of us are going to have to work together to come up with solutions.

AT: You’re the first Democrat and the first Black woman representing your district. What does being the first mean to you? And what do you want people to know about the area that you represent? 

Mayes: I’m humbled and feel blessed to have been entrusted with this position in an area that is around 69% white, and the African-American population makes up less than 20%. And to be the first, I realize that there is probably a level of expectation that surpasses those that have been before me. But I’m ready to take on the challenge.

AT: There were really serious, disgusting allegations against your opponent. What was it like campaigning under those circumstances and how do you think that played a role in the results?

Mayes: From a campaign perspective, we kept campaigning. It never really factored to me that I needed to do anything different, or I needed go in a different direction. I knew that people were counting on me to continue to run a campaign of integrity, a campaign of facts and truth, and that was my goal from Day One, and that’s what I continued to do. There were moments where I did receive messages that I felt were inappropriate and unnecessary, but I understand the climate that we’re in. People may not have understood or were angry about the outcome, but I knew that people were counting on me.

AT: What are you doing to celebrate? 

Mayes: I am going to have a small intimate gathering for my volunteers, who are really the real winners in this particular situation. They took a chance on me. They worked tirelessly. They deserve all of the praise. It’s a small group, but we’re small and mighty, and that’s how I want to celebrate. I want them to know how much they mean to me and how much they mean to this district. Because if it were not for them, we wouldn’t be here. This campaign is so much bigger than me, because now there are people that have felt as if they had had no voice that now have a voice at the table.

So, come January, I have a lot of work to do, but I’m ready to support my colleagues and to educate others about what’s really going on in the schools, how teachers are really feeling, and how students are really performing. I’m excited about the opportunity.

In 2010, the Tea Party movement enabled rightwing Republicans to win both houses of the North Carolina state legislature, called the General Assembly. For a time Republicans held a supermajority and could do whatever they wanted. They used their power to limit the authority of the governor when he was a Democrat. And they did terrible damage to the state’s public schools and teachers.

North Carolina was once considered the most progressive Southern state, but Republicans forfeited that claim. Teachers’ salaries fell behind other states, public school funding stalled, while the legislature approved charter schools (including for-profit charter chains) and vouchers.

In the November 3 election, the blue wave swept North Carolina. Democrats gained control of the House, and Republicans retained a majority of the Senate by only one vote.

The Carolina Public Press reported:

With most of the vote counted by late Tuesday night, it appeared as though Democratic candidates flipped 25 Republican seats. However, some races remain too close to count. Democrats also maintained every one of their incumbent legislative seats. 

Democrats’ state House win will restore power to Democratic Gov. Josh Stein’s veto. During the 2025-2026 legislative session, House Republicans were one seat shy of a supermajority, but were able to secure enough swing Democrats’ votes to override key governor vetoes on DEI policy, immigration issues, energy legislation and more. 

One of the members of the House who was defeated was Tricia Cotham. She served in the House as a Democrat from 2007-2017. As a Democrat, she supported abortion rights and opposed vouchers. She gained a certain notoriety when she campaigned and won as a Democrat in 2022, but then switched to the Republican Party in 2023, giving it a supermajority and the votes it needed to restrict abortion and enact vouchers, immune to a gubernatorial veto. She was given a safe red district by her new party, but that district went blue on Tuesday.

Last night was a big night, a great night for public schools, writes Carol Burris, executive director of the Network for Public Education. Carol was a teacher of Spanish for many years, then a high school principal on Long Island in New York. She was selected as New York State Principal of the Year by her statewide colleagues. As executive director of NPE, she excels as an organizer, a researcher, a writer, and an analyst of statistical data. We are so fortunate to have her leadership in the battle to preserve public schools against privatization and corporate interests. And, at the same time, to advocate for ways to improve our public schools.

She writes:

Last night was an extraordinary night for those who love public education.

For me, the highlight was Gina Hinojosa’s election as governor of Texas. Gina came into politics as a mom. She ran for the Austin school board to keep her son’s school, and other neighborhood schools, from closing. In the Texas House, no one has defended public schools more fiercely, fought vouchers harder, or been more skeptical of charter schools. She has promised to fire Education Commissioner Mike Morath on day one and end state takeovers of school districts, including takeovers like Houston’s, where the failure of a single school was used to seize an entire district. You can hear Gina’s address at the 2025 Network for Public Education Conference here.

James Talarico’s Senate victory drew more of the headlines, but Gina’s win should not be overlooked. She beat a three-term incumbent who had never lost a general election and who outspent her by tens of millions of dollars. Talarico’s opponent was Ken Paxton, a scandal-plagued attorney general. I suspect Gina helped bring Latino voters to Talarico as much as he helped bring a broader electorate to her.

Talarico’s win is also good news for public schools. He is soft on charters, but he is a fierce opponent of vouchers and has publicly opposed the federal tax-credit voucher. His arrival should add momentum to Senator Mark Kelly’s Keep Public Funds in Public Schools Act, which would repeal it.

He will be joined by other strong allies of public education: Abdul El-Sayed of Michigan, Roy Cooper of North Carolina, and Sherrod Brown, who returns to the Senate from Ohio and has always stood with public schools. This matters. Corporate Democrats such as Cory Booker and Michael Bennet have too often sided with Republicans on school choice. The new Senate Democrats can help move good bills forward and block further expansion of the federal Charter Schools Program.

Ohio delivered another big win: Governor-elect Amy Acton, a strong supporter of public schools who earned the endorsement of the Ohio Education Association.

In the House, I don’t yet know where many of the newly elected members stand. But a larger Democratic majority should help us build support for reining in the federal Charter Schools Program and outvote the minority of pro-charter Democrats.

A pro-public education agenda for the new Congress

  1. Repeal the federal tax-credit voucher.
  2. Pass the CHARTER Act to end federal funding for charter schools run by for-profit operators.
  3. Hold the Department of Education accountable:
    • Release the program funds it has frozen.
    • Cut the federal Charter Schools Program.
    • Rescind its anti-DEI policies.

As more results come in, I hope more pro-public education state legislatures will emerge as well.

~Carol Burris

Gina Hinojosa, Diane, and Carol Burris at the Conference of the Network for Public Education in Columbus, Ohio, in 2025

A journalist in Texas wrote the following. He/she lives in Austin and requested anonymity to avoid reprisals. I have double-checked the information shared. It is accurate.

The journalist describes Governor Greg Abbott’s tactic to destroy public education: state takeovers. This allows the state to dismiss the locally elected school board and replace it with people loyal to Governor Abbott and State Superintendent Mike Morath, a non-educator picked by Abbott. After the state takeover, teachers leave, enrollment declines..public schools being to the state, not to the district.

The journalist wrote the following to me:

Texas public schools are under attack. And no Texas district is being attacked on as many fronts as Austin ISD.

 State policies and targeted investigations are taking a toll, pulling time, energy, and funds from the real work of supporting Austin’s students, teachers, and campus communities. The district is facing a long list of challenges, all created or exacerbated by many years of anti-public school policies from state leaders. Students and teachers feel the impact on campuses every day. Families are leaving the district. Budgets are becoming tighter each year. Charters and vouchers are siphoning students from public schools and concentrating need at many campuses. And despite this community’s deep belief in engaging education, teaching is increasingly focused on testing – the near-inevitable result of a punitive high-stakes testing environment.

 Austin is sometimes described as the blueberry in the tomato soup – the brightest blue community in what has long been a deeply red state. That makes the district a favorite target for state leaders, who routinely attack it to score political points.Students, teachers, families, and the city are suffering as those attacks weaken a district in that should be among the strongest urban districts in the country.

 The community shows up for Austin ISD schools, and people across the economic spectrum continue to choose Austin ISD schools, which educate a mix of students who are diverse in every way. About half come from families classified as having economic disadvantage and half do not. About half are Hispanic, almost a third are emergent bilingual, and nearly one in ten are immigrants from all over the world.

 Austin ISD’s school board looks a lot like the city itself – racially and economically diverse, highly educated, and politically progressive. All were elected with strong support from their local union and their local communities. All serve as volunteers in a role that demands many hours and invites public critique along with the joy. All have seen the impact of state policies on Texas public schools. Many are longtime public education advocates. And all have become far too familiar withthe power the Texas Education Agency holds over Texas districts.

 In Texas, state takeovers are becoming a go-to remedy. Houston ISD was the first big district to fall, in 2023. Then, last year, the pace escalated. A single school with five F ratings in a row can trigger a takeover. Four more districts are now under state control, including Fort Worth ISD – another of the state’s largest urban districts. When the 2026-27 school year began, some 250,000 Texas students walked into classrooms that are now under state control.

 It’s an unprecedented experiment, and an aggressive exercise of state power over local communities. Now Austin ISD – rated a B under the state’s narrow accountability system – is the latest Texas district at risk of state takeover. And that is just the biggest threat among many, many others.

 Here’s a short list of challenges Austin ISD is facing right now:

 

• Investigation of student walkouts

State leaders have targeted Austin ISD for a special investigation after students at many campuses walked out to protest ICE. In a community as diverse as Austin, issues involving immigration are felt deeply and personally. Their protests were part of a student movement across the state and the country in late January. Yet Governor Greg Abbot and Attorney General Ken Paxton have focused special attention on Austin ISD, with an investigation that still has not been completed. The Texas Education Agency has warned that walkouts could lead to a state takeover.

 

• Investigation of which bathroom a single student has used

Attorney General Paxton has also targeted Austin ISD for alleged violations of the state’s “bathroom bill,” which requires people at sites including public schools to use the bathroom that matches their sex at birth. The bill depends on people reporting districts for alleged violations – something that happened two times when someone complained about the bathroom a single transgender student was using at an Austin ISD high school, which was followed by a complaint at the district’s performing arts center. The law holds the district accountable, allowing fines of up to $5000 a day for documented violations. But the law also allows the full weight of the state to be weaponized against individual students – children in public schools.

 

• Funding crisis

For years, public education funding has failed to keep up with inflation or a long and growing list of mandates from the state. Texas consistently ranks in the bottom ten states in per-student funding. Yet schools must also pay for expensive security mandates, serve students who are emergent bilingual or who receive special education services despite funding that leaves immense gaps, and follow many other state demands that are neither optional nor funded. Across the state, dozens of schools have closed, class sizes are growing, programs and student supports are being cut, and teachers are quitting or taking second jobs. Texas offers no funding for many things it simply does not require, including school nurses and school librarians. Transportation is funded at a fraction of the actual cost to districts. In Austin ISD, the 2026-27 budget included about $205 million in deeply painful cuts. The district closed eleven campuses. They are selling property to help plug the holes. And still funding is not keeping up with costs. That crisis has been deepened by the passage of a $1 billion statewide voucher after many years of successful resistance by the Texas Legislature. Passage was only possible after the sitting governor primaried legislators who voted against vouchers, then had President Trump call lawmakers the morning of the vote. The cost is expected to double this year.

 

• State comptroller audit

At a campaign stop in El Paso in August, Governor Greg Abbott asked the Texas Comptroller to investigate the use of taxpayer money at up to four Texas school districts. The goal, according to the Governor, was to prevent funds from “being absorbed by central office growth, administrative bloat, consultants, and the web of noninstructional bureaucracy.” News reports say districts are being asked for data far beyond what an audit focused on the use of funds would require. The list includes lists of library books, demands for documents related to DEI, scrutiny of foreign workers, and information about Social Security numbers that advocates fear is an attempt to understand how many students may be undocumented.

 

• Investigation of Pride Week celebration

Austin ISD has a long history of celebrating Pride Week. Since 2014, that meant supporting activities that included flying Pride flags at district facilities, participating as a district in the community’s Pride Parade, offering age-appropriate activities focused on respect for other people, and supporting campuses that chose to host their own after-school events for families. Staff and families have often said that they have chosen the district because of AISD’s welcoming climate. And the district continued to celebrate Pride Week – along with Juneteenth, Cesar Chavez Day, and other important community celebrations – even after trustees received a death threat targeting the parade. Since 2024, AISD’s Pride Week celebrations have grown smaller and smaller, and less and less visible. In 2026, the district chose not to participate in the community’s parade, inviting PTA leaders to step into the district’s place. As a result, the parade shrank from dozens of people with district support to just a handful. And still, in April, the Texas Education Agency began an investigation into Austin ISD for Pride Week. That investigation was launched in response to a complaint not from within the community, but from a conservative member of the State Board of Education who represents a district in Fort Worth, about 200 miles away. On social media, he called for defunding the district and for a criminal investigation of the superintendent. He also shared concerns that if the practice is not stopped in Austin ISD, it will expand to other communities in the state.

 This is not normal, even in Texas, except for Austin ISD. Each investigation or audit takes precious resources that no Texas district has to spare. Time and funds are diverted from the work that matters most – of educating students, supporting teachers, and inspiring a lifelong love of learning that prepares Austin’s students for the futures they deserve. 

 It does not have to be this way. And it’s both painful and promising to imagine what might be if the State of Texas would offer support rather than sanctions, and if they would also simply get out of the district’s way.

 Austin ISD has a strong board with a broad mix of highly relevant experience. All nine members were endorsed by the district’s union, Education Austin, and all serve by working long hours without pay. Six members are former K-12 educators in Texas public schools – including five who taught in the district, one who worked as the district’s head of multilingual education, and several who are current or former professors in programs that teach future teachers. Another is an educational anthropologist who teaches at UT and ran programs for students in the district. Another is a journalist with a law degree and a long background in advocacy and family engagement. And another is a former foster child who was in the first graduating class of Austin ISD’s Ann Richards School for Young Women Leaders, ranked as one of the top public high schools in the country. Another worked as an accountant after a career as a teacher. Together, the board holds five masters’ degrees, one law degree, and two Ph.Ds. Another trustee is earning a doctorate now. They have hired a superintendent who is a graduate of the district and the son of a longtime teacher. He’s an unconventional choice – with an MBA, an engineering degree, and a career in construction and district operations – but he has also brought stability after a series of rapid superintendent turnovers. And he has worked with the board and community to navigate immensely challenging times.

 As they have tackled issue after issue, district leaders have also managed to do important and thoughtful work in many areas. The community approved a $2.4 billion bond and a crucial increase in the tax rate for operations with powerful support from district voters. The district has created systems to focus resources where they are needed most – essential but also not easy in a district with such a broad range of economic opportunity and economic need. They cleared a large backlog of special education evaluations that grew during the pandemic. They have sharply reduced the number of F-rated campuses and steadily grown the number of highly rated campuses – a measure that must be a focus no matter how flawed and opaque the state’s metrics are. And they are seeing impressive results from a grant-funded investment in early literacy.

 And still, Austin ISD risks being taken over by the state.

 The community’s worry about a takeover goes far beyond the loss of elected control. Their fears are also based in facts about what has happened since the state took control of Houston ISD. State leaders routinely call the takeover an unparalleled success, citing a higher rating for the district and near zero F rated schools. But the costs have been immense – of lost opportunity, financial cost, and damage to community and careers.

 Reports document practices that serve scores but sacrifice student learning – limiting access to 8th grade Algebra by systematically holding some students back, gaming college readiness measures in ways that are legal but offer little benefit, removing both libraries and librarians, and reducing teaching to timed and scripted lessons. Campuses have closed, enrollment has plummeted by more than 20,000 students, and teachers are fleeing. Hundreds of their replacements are uncertified. And the state-appointed leaders have eaten into the district’s fund balance by pulling hundreds of millions from reserves in ways that will be impossible to sustain.

 Good reporting and strategic advocacy are helping the whole story from Houston ISD reach more people. Our state owes deep thanks to Community Voices for Public Education for its advocacy from the beginning, the Commission on the Takeover of HISD for its new in-depth report, state and local education union leaders for advocating and organizing, elected trustees for becoming the resistance, and doctoral student Dan Dawer for work to examine the takeover through an academic lens.

 In Austin, a group called Keep Austin Schools Independent has formed to inform and organize our community. We are also lucky to have strong trustee candidates who are stepping up, not knowing what their role will be but knowing their voices will matter.

 Takeovers are looming for more Texas districts. 

 Education is on the ballot in Texas in a way it has never been before. And the results of the election could make things far better or far worse, not just here in Austin, but also for public schools across our state. Voters in the Democratic primaries chose proven public education supporters up and down the ballot. And for people who know that change is needed for Texas public schools, Gina Hinojosa, the Democratic nominee for Texas Governor, is carrying a whole state’s hopes. She’s the mom of children who chose Austin ISD schools, a former AISD school board president, and a Texas House member who served her community and fought for Texas students on the public education committee. Her office became a place of pilgrimage for public education advocates, who would visit their own representatives, then stop by her office, too.

 A huge amount is at stake – not only for Austin, but for public education statewide. Dozens of Texas districts are just one or two years away from potential takeover. Schools are struggling after years of underfunding. And increasingly, the state’s vision of education is focused on the narrow measure of standardized tests – despite clear evidence that families and educators want and need something more for the 5 million students of Texas

Julian Vasquez-Heilig is a scholar and activist who has been a leader in studying and promoting equal access to educational opportunity for all students.

He writes here about the consequences for Texas students, teachers, and communities if Gina Hinojosa manages to get elected Governor of Texas next week. She is heavily outspent by Governor Greg Abbott, who is seeking his fourth term, yet the polls show that the race is virtually tied. The latest reports show that Abbott has a campaign chest of nearly $100 million, while Hinojosa has raised $7-8 million.

Abbott has been a forceful advocate for privatization of public schools, pushing the Republican-controlled legislature to authorize charter schools and vouchers. Rural Republicans opposed vouchers, so Abbott got $12 million from Pennsylvania billionaire Jeff Yass to defeat the anti-voucher Republicans.

If Abbott wins, expect a doubling of the voucher budget from $1 billion a year to $2 billion a year. That increase was recently proposed by Don Huffines, the state’s chief financial officer. Expect an increase in funding for privately-managed charter schools and less oversight. Expect a steady erosion of public schools and low pay for teachers.

Vasquez-Heilig describes what to expect if Hinojosa wins:

The midterm vote in the United States could do more than change who holds political power; it could determine the future of education.

First, congrats to Lula for his big victory this week in the national Brazilian elections! Incidentally, a Brazilian university recruited me for a Fulbright project that past year examining how Brazil was recovering and reinventing its education system after Jair Bolsonaro’s presidency. After the invitation, I applied and Fulbright faculty peer reviewers scored and approved the proposal. Unfortunately, the U.S. State Department then rejected it. I was not given an explanation establishing why they rejected the invited and reviewer approved Fulbright, although I couldn’t help wondering whether examining the innovation of the education system after Bolsonaro was an uncomfortable subject for the Trump Administration.

The experience left me thinking about questions much closer to home. What would it take to reimagine and rebuild education in the United States after the midterms? More specifically, what might be possible in Texas after more than a decade under Governor Greg Abbott as a case study? 

I spent eight years as a professor at the University of Texas at Austin, studying educational equity, civil rights, school accountability, and privatization. During my time in Texas, I witnessed how nakedly political decisions shaped educational opportunities for millions of students and the educators who served them. With State Representative Gina Hinojosa now challenging Abbott for governor, I have examined her official education platform and considering what could change if Texas takes a different political direction. 

The possibilities extend well beyond one state, considering that the Republican’s ideas for education are all over the place (charter schools, vouchers, banning curriculum etc). Texas offers a compelling case study of how shifts in political leadership after the midterms could reshape educational policy, governance, and public investment in states transitioning from Republican to Democratic control. What happens in Texas could offer important lessons for the future of public education across the country.

For my case study, I examine ten possibilities. Some of the ideas below are commitments Hinojosa has publicly made. Others are reforms I believe deserve consideration, particularly in higher education and financial accountability.

1. The Texas Education Agency Would Get an Educator as Commissioner

Hinojosa has explicitly promised to remove Texas Education Agency non-educator Commissioner Mike Morath and appoint an educator. This could fundamentally change the agency’s relationship with schools. The next commissioner would bring direct experience with teaching and learning to an organization responsible for overseeing millions of students, school accountability, state interventions, and billions in education spending.

The consequential question would be whether that professional background will actually translate into different institutional priorities. Texas educators have spent years operating under accountability pressures, staffing shortages, and extensive state requirements. A commissioner with educator experience could approach those challenges with a different understanding of what teachers and students need, although successful administration would also require considerable policy and management expertise.

Earlier I provide some persepctives on California’s newly implemented commissioner position here.

2. Houston and Other State-Controlled Districts Could Return to Their Communities

Hinojosa promises to end state takeovers and restore local governance. Houston ISD offers the most consequential example, with state-appointed leaders making major decisions about instruction, staffing, and campus operations after the 2023 state takeover ostensibly due to single test score in a single high school. For the Republican in Texas, local control has meant controlling people locally.

The educational record deserves careful examination. State officials and takeover supporters cite improved academic ratings at historically struggling campuses in Houston, while critics have raised concerns about teacher turnover (about 12,000 have left the district), instructional restrictions and canned curriculum, elimination of an elected school board, and the manipulation of student populations to show fake results. A transition back to community governance would produce actual improvements while restoring democratic accountability.

Fort Worth, Austin, and other districts facing or experiencing state takeover present similar questions about who makes decisions and how communities regain authority over their schools.

3. Testing and Accountability System Would Be Revised

Hinojosa has proposed ending STAAR, pausing A through F accountability ratings, and developing a new system. Her campaign reports that TEA has awarded more than $1.7 billion to testing vendors during Abbott’s governorship.

During my years at UT Austin, I studied how high-stakes accountability affected schools serving historically marginalized communities in Texas. That research shaped my advocacy for community-based accountabilityand multiple measures of school success. This revised system could place greater emphasis on academic growth, graduation, student engagement, access to advanced coursework, and the opportunity to learn. Such changes would require legislation and a credible replacement system that gives families actually useful information about school performance.

4. Voucher Spending Could Face a Comprehensive Audit

Texas has committed $1 billion to its new private school voucher program, which Hinojosa proposes to end. A comprehensive financial review could examine who received funds, what providers charged, whether expenses met legal requirements, and whether safeguards adequately protected taxpayers.

Other states offer reasons to investigate. In Arizona, the media has reviewed records showing that education savings account money had been spent on travel-related expenses across 44 states and 13 countries. More than 100 accounts were associated with at least $21,000 in spending at Disney parks, Disney stores, and Disney’s streaming service. Some expenditures may have been approved under existing program rules, which makes the distinction between legal spending and appropriate public spending particularly important.

Texas investigators could carefully examine whether its own program permits comparable purchases, whether vendors are properly screened, and whether families and providers comply with spending restrictions. Arizona’s experience is a warning about oversight. I recently heard at the Network for Public Education conference that Florida has a $1 billion state budget deficit due to unlimited vouchers; that’s another warning.

5. Charter School Financial Misconduct Could Face Stronger Enforcement

Texas already has a documented history of serious charter school spending controversies. Consider IDEA Public Schools, one of the nation’s largest charter networks. Its leadership faced scrutiny over plans involving private aircraft and expenditures of approximately $400,000 on premium San Antonio Spurs tickets and luxury seating. Reports also described a proposed private jet lease, executive travel expenses, related-party business arrangements, and the acquisition of a boutique hotel. Former CEO Tom Torkelson departed with a reported $900,000 severance package. In 2024, TEA placed IDEA under conservatorship following a years-long investigation into financial and operational misconduct.

Texas could strengthen financial disclosure requirements, investigate conflicts of interest, recover improperly spent funds where legally possible, and refer substantiated fraud to law enforcement. Prosecutions should follow evidence of criminal violations rather than assumptions about an institution’s charter status.

6. Abbott’s University Regents Could Be Replaced

Texas governors exercise substantial influence over higher education through appointments to university governing boards. At the University of Texas System, nine regents serve staggered six-year terms and require Senate confirmation. A new governor would inherit those existing terms. However, three UT regent terms are scheduled to expire in February 2027, creating an early opportunity for appointments if successors are confirmed. 

New appointments could change the governing boards’ approach to presidential selection, academic freedom, institutional performance, and faculty governance. They could also prompt closer examination of whether political relationships have been given undue weight in university leadership appointments.

Hinojosa has not announced a comprehensive regent replacement agenda, and current regents cannot simply be dismissed for their political associations in theory. Nevertheless, governing board appointments would be an important part of any change in Texas higher education policy.

7. University Presidents, Provosts, and Deans Could Face New Evaluations

Changes to governing boards could eventually produce changes in university leadership. Presidents are selected and evaluated through governing structures, while presidents exercise substantial authority over the appointment and dismissal of provosts, deans, and other academic administrators. The University of Texas System’s rules generally delegate responsibility for appointing and dismissing institutional administrative officers to university presidents. 

A new governing board could examine whether presidents were selected through credible processes, whether administrative appointments emphasized academic qualifications, and whether leaders delivered results in enrollment, research, student success, and institutional governance. Where community-wide evaluations establish serious leadership failures, governing boards and presidents could make personnel changes consistent with applicable rules and contracts. 

8. Black, Latino, Indigenous, and Gender Studies Could Regain Support

Texas universities have faced substantial political and legislative pressure concerning diversity initiatives, academic programs, and the teaching of race and gender. A change in state leadership could reopen discussions about the important place of Black Studies, Latino Studies, Indigenous Studies, Gender Studies, and related fields within public universities in our democracy.

These disciplines contribute to historical understanding, scholarship, public policy, and students’ ability to examine complex social questions. Decisions about their academic standing should involve faculty expertise, scholarly standards, student demand, and institutional missions.

Restoring programs affected by state policies could require legislative changes, governing board action, institutional funding, and faculty recruitment. Hinojosa has not explicitly promised these restorations, but her administration’s approach to higher education appointments and governance could influence their future.

9. Teachers Could Receive Higher Pay and Greater Professional Influence

Hinojosa’s education platform calls for raising teacher salaries and reviewing vendor contracts that her campaign considers wasteful or improper. She proposes using recovered resources to support educators.

Texas would need to determine how much money contract reviews could actually recover and whether those savings would support recurring compensation increases. Significant statewide salary changes would likely require legislative appropriations.

10. We Can Reconsider the Relationship Between Education and Political Power

For too long, political leaders, including the governors, education commissioners, and state legislatures, have used the power of government to exert oppressive pressure on public schools, educators, universities, and the communities they serve. Through state takeovers, punitive accountability systems, restrictions on academic freedom, increasingly centralized decision-making, and privatizing our schools, communities have too often been treated as problems to be managed rather than partners capable of developing solutions. Political authority has been used to impose decisions while diminishing the voices of parents, teachers, students, and locally elected representatives.

A different approach in Texas and elsewhere after the midterms would begin by recognizing that communities are the solution, not the problem. That principle should apply equally to red and blue communities, rural towns and major cities, and neighborhoods across every region. Families and educators understand their local schools, their children’s needs, and the challenges facing their communities. Their knowledge deserves meaningful influence over educational decisions. Restoring public trust requires moving away from political coercion and toward shared responsibility, meaningful local governance, transparent accountability, and genuine community participation.

After the midterms we will have an opportunity to reconsider how political power is exercised in education. Governors, commissioners, and legislators should use their authority to support communities, expand educational opportunity, and provide the resources schools need to succeed. The ultimate measure of leadership should be whether public institutions strengthen the capacity of people to shape their own futures. Regardless of whether a community votes red or blue, its children deserve excellent public schools, its educators deserve professional respect, and its residents deserve a meaningful voice in the decisions affecting their lives. A stronger education system can emerge when state leaders begin trusting communities as essential partners in educational improvement.

Years from now, our children may not remember who won the midterms. But they will live with what the winners chose to build, whose voices they listened to, and whose futures they believed were worth investing in.

Did you know that reading fiction is inportant for your social and emotional development? Did you know the the widely adopted Common Core state Standards actually diminish the reading of fiction in school? The standards describe the percentage of time that should be devoted to “informational text” and fiction. As students grow older, teachers are supposed to reduce fiction and favor informational text. Studies have shown that fiction-reading has declined, which was the intended effect of the Common Core.

This article explains why the reduction of fiction reading harms students.

Richard Sima wrote the following column for The Washington Post.

Curling up with a good book isn’t just enjoyable. It’s also good for your brain.
Reading in general — newspapers, magazines, nonfiction books — has been linked to slower rates of cognitive decline in older adults and even longer lives.

But reading fiction may have unique benefits. For example, the amount of fiction people read seems to be a better predictor of language ability than nonfiction, research finds. And, perhaps even more importantly, research has found that fiction is linked to better social cognition — our ability to think about and interact with other people — and an increased understanding of the world as a complex place.
Why? Fiction forces you to imagine a story’s world and characters. It makes you grapple with different perspectives, mentally inhabiting distinct points of view, according to Nick Buttrick, an assistant professor of psychology at the University of Wisconsin at Madison.

This can help us find “better insight into our own experiences, insight into the experiences of others who are very different from us,” said Raymond Mar, a professor of psychology at York University in Toronto, who recently wrote a review on the benefits of reading narrative fiction. “It just tends to evoke a form of reflection and contemplation, which can only be good for us.”
Why reading is actually social
Social health is important for overall health. And it turns out that reading, though often thought of as a solitary activity, can boost our social abilities.
To understand why, it helps to look at how reading shapes us as we grow.
Between ages 4 and 6, children develop a theory of mind — the ability to understand that others have different beliefs, perspectives and feelings. Studies find that children exposed to more storybooks are further along this developmental milestone than those exposed to fewer ones, Mar said.

A 2025 meta-analysis of 21 studies found that children who read more storybooks had more empathy. And there is evidence that empathy and reading go both ways. Better reading comprehension was a predictor of empathy later in life, while empathy also was a predictor of better reading ability, according to a 2024 study of more than 900 children. And adolescents who read more for fun became more social adults, a 2023 study found.
Reading fiction “presents to us a complex cognitive and emotional simulation of the social world,” which is useful in the real world, Mar said.
The power of storytelling
These benefits may be due, in part, to the power of storytelling.
Neuroimaging studies find that brain networks involved in understanding stories overlap with brain networks needed for theory of mind. This suggests that “while engaging with stories, we’re also pulling online the same kinds of brain networks that we use to understand other people,” said Mar, who wrote a review about these studies.

Other forms of storytelling, such as television and movies, may provide similar benefits, but “one of the things that you do when you read is you have to construct the world” in your head, Buttrick said. “The world is not given to you. You have to do the work of imagining.”
This extra work may amplify the benefits of engaging in a story.
Spending time with our favorite story characters may also help us feel connected. “Even if our friends aren’t around and can’t get together, we can always open up a book,” Mar said.
Reading can be a social activity, too, one that reinforces the joys and benefits of reading. Book clubs, shared reading organizations and social media communities like BookTok can connect us with other readers and add yet another layer to building our social cognitive abilities.
Talking to others about the books you read means you’re not only imagining the characters in a story, but also gaining an understanding of how other people respond to those characters, Buttrick said.

Exposure to difference
Beyond helping our social cognition, reading fiction can expand our world and our understanding of its complexities. Good authors are master observers of the human condition and can expose us to experiences outside our comfort zone.

“Reading is an encounter with difference, with a different kind of mind, a different place, a different approach to the world,” Buttrick said. “And so a lot of the places where I think reading is most interesting are in places where it smashes this up with difference as strongly as it can.”
In a 2022 study of more than 5,000 people published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin, Buttrick and his colleagues found that those who grew up reading more literary fiction were more likely to become adults with more complex worldviews — with more nuance, more psychological richness and intellectual humility.

“I think if we want to live in a world in which everyone’s treated as something like an individual, knowing that the world is complex, especially socially complex, is probably really good,” he said.
But there are inherent difficulties with studying the effects of reading because “reading is a part of a person’s life,” Buttrick said. “And when people have more time, more space to read, more inclination to read, they’re not doing that at random.”
Benefits probably take time to accrue, and socioeconomic status is a strong predictor of reading behavior and ability, though a 2025 study of more than 14,000 students found that leisure reading had the largest benefits for children whose parents had less education.
“Successful art resonates with a great number of people because it captures something about being human that appeals to us and maybe that we don’t fully understand,” Mar said.

How to read more
Start slow. Mar recommends getting off your phone before going to bed and spending that time reading instead. “Maybe you have to build up to an hour,” he said. “But you can start with 15 minutes and then work to 30 minutes, then 45 in an hour before you go to sleep. It’s probably a good thing.”
Cultivate a habit. Consistency is key. “I don’t think that any one book will change a person’s life,” Buttrick said. “I think it’s the accretion of lots of books, you know, reading again and again and again, that really has an effect on how people think about the world more broadly.”
Dive into the vast diversity of reading. Different forms of reading — short stories, graphic novels and fan fiction, for example — also count. Given his busy work schedule and reading of academic journals, Mar prefers to read short stories. “It’s hard for me to commit to a book,” said Mar, who has most recently read the works of Irish writer Claire Keegan.

(Buttrick is currently reading Spencer Ackerman’s “Reign of Terror” and gearing up to read William Vollmann’s 3,000-plus-page novel, “A Table for Fortune.” And I’ve been reading through my collection of Terry Pratchett, who is a hilarious satirical writer, including “Small Gods,” which tackles religion, and “The Truth,” which is about journalism.)
Audiobooks can be beneficial, too. Buttrick said audiobooks still count as reading. In fact, the format may make certain books easier to grasp. Listening to James Joyce’s “Ulysses” not only makes it easier to understand and funnier, but also makes “you realize how much of it is just a song,” Buttrick said.
Remember that reading should be enjoyable. “I don’t think of reading as a monastic experience that you have to do alone at night in order to grow as a person,” Buttrick said. Lean into what you enjoy.

Make it social. Book clubs are excellent and flourishing. It’s nice to have an accountability partner and others with whom to share perspectives, Buttrick said.
Read unselfconsciously. Reading is for enjoyment. “A lot of times people seem embarrassed about the things that they’ve been reading,” Mar said. But “there’s nothing to be embarrassed about whatever you’re reading.”
Do you have a question about human behavior or neuroscience? Email BrainMatters@washpost.com and we may answer it in a future column.

Richard Sima is a neuroscientist turned award-winning science journalist who writes the “Brain Matters” column about mental health and why we do, think and feel the things we do.